All Clud / Dumbarton Rock

All Clud  / Dumbarton Rock
All Clud / Dumbarton Rock

Wednesday, 20 April 2016

Northumbrian Control of the Old North

After the Northumbrian Conquest in the mid 600s, we then have a period of around two hundred years where the areas of modern English Cumbria, the Scottish Borders, Dumfriesshire and Lothian are under Anglo-Saxon rule as part of the kingdom of Northumbria.  The extent of Anglo-Saxon cultural and political influence is found in church dedications to St Oswald and St Cuthbert (though in all probability Cuthbert was a Briton by origin).  This includes two Kirkoswalds in Ayrshire and a dedication to St Oswald at Cathcart [25].  Anglo-Saxon sculpture is found at Dunbar, Aberlady as well as Jedburgh and Melrose. Anglo-Saxon metalwork at Aberlady dates from the 8th-9th Centuries. In most cases, the Anglo-Saxons took over existing monastic British sites [23].

At Bewcastle the Anglo-Saxon cross dated from around 670. It is in the churchyard of St Cuthbert's and records in Anglo-Saxon runes that it was set up in memory of Alcfrith of Northumbria who became king in 670.  Further west is the Ruthwell Cross in Dumfriesshire, from the same period, also with an Anglo-Saxon inscription [26]. As well as these great crosses, there are examples of pre-Viking, Anglo-Saxon cross styles at Beckermet on the west coast of Cumberland and at Penrith.

This does not presume a wholesale Anglicisation, because the monuments are for the ruling elite, who would be Anglo-Saxon, but in addition, how a man carves a stone does not tell you what language he spoke, or what he felt his identity to be.  Alex Woolf discusses the history of the ideas that the Anglo-Saxons came en masse from the Continent and wiped out the Britons, or that only a warrior elite came and everyone else remained British. Woolf's point that a language that the English learned by the Britons would show a considerable influence from their Brittonic dialects if they only had their landlord or themselves to practice on [23]. However, I would note that they say that the English of the Scottish Highlands is the purest spoken anywhere and while Irish English has Irish influence on it, it is still Standard English rather than a Creole.

Woolf also quotes the West Saxon laws that give the rate of fines payable for Saxons and Welshmen. The Welsh (Britons) are worth less but there are Welsh nobles in the Saxon king's court who are still worth five times more than an English churl. Woolf notes that similar low wergeld for Britons is payable under the Northumbrian laws. Woolf says that the existence of Welsh nobles in an Anglo-Saxon court suggests that some areas under the Anglo-Saxon kingdom are still ruled by their British lords, albeit under the patronage of the Anglo-Saxons.

We know that the Anglo-Saxons had a series of monasteries across the area that was later the Kingdom of Cumbria. One of these was at Dacre, west of Penrith. Probably at Workington, Brigham. Certainly at Carlisle, and of course Whithorn. Ruthwell, Hoddom, Thornhill and Closeburn [27] Bailey believes that Northumbrian churches were being granted land west of the Pennines by the second half of the sixth century.

The Northumbrian lords ruled their new lands from fortified centres at Bamburgh and Dunbar, as well as from Yeavering and Millfield in Northumberland and Sprouston in Roxburghshire,  but they took over the native British systems of land organisation [10]

Bede wrote a history of the life of St Cuthbert [28]. Cuthbert was born around 634. He was a shepherd according to Bede in some "distant mountains" when he had a vision of angels related to the death of Aidan, Bishop of Lindisfarne. After this he devoted himself to God and became a monk at Melrose. Bede visited Carlisle (in 685), which he says was corruptly called by the English Luel to speak to the English queen. Northumbrian control over Carlisle appears secure at this time and English speakers were present. Cuthbert also visited the English named hermit Herebert on an island on Derwentwater.

In 685, King Ecgfrith gave Cartmel and all its Britons to Cuthbert. Another Anglian cross with an Anglo-Saxon runic inscription was found at Great Urswick in Furness dating from the Northumbrian period.Ecgfrith also gave Carlisle to Cuthbert around this time. Potts notes that Anglo-Saxon chroniclers reports that the British fled or were cleared out and Anglo-Saxons planted in their stead. [29]

Simeon of Durham tells us that in 756 King Eadberht along with King Unust of the Picts received the Britons in alliance in the city of Alcwith, which the editor notes is the Alclut of Bede [30]. The Britons of Strathclyde clearly had some political autonomy but suffered at the hands of the Northumbrians. English language place-names and dedications of churches to Northumbrian saints - for example to St Oswald at Cathcart, which suggest that the expansion of Northumbrian power was accompanied by Anglo-Saxon settlement in what had been wholly British speaking territory [31]

In 759. Ethelwald known as Moll, which sounds suspiciously, but inexplicably .like the Welsh Moel, referring to his baldness - began to reign.  In 764, Frithwald, another Anglo-Saxon name, who was bishop at Whithorn, died.  Ethelwald Moll's son, Aethelred took the sons of an enemy from York and drowned them in Wonwaldremere  (?Windermere).  He allegedly killed another rival at Maryport. This source for the location of this act at Maryport seems unclear to me but it is reported on different websites [32].  The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle states that his body was deposited at Tynemouth. It should be noted that throughout this century, Northumbria was in frequent civil war.

The Vikings raided Lindisfarne in 793 but did not disturb Cuthbert's relics. However, in 844, they killed Raedwald, King of Northumbria and the monks decided to move the relics for saftey to Norham. In 867 the Vikings captured York and killed the Northumbrian King. In 875, a Viking fleet was anchored in the River Team and the Bishop of Lindisfarne with Eadred the Abbot of Carlisle (note his Anglo-Saxon name) decided to move the relics again from Lindisfarne. They stopped at Melrose, Durham and in Lancashire and Yorkshire, allegedly wandering all over the lands held by the Northumbrians at that time.  The itinerary included Whithorn. Daniel Elsworth has recently argued that the relics did not cross the Solway to Whithorn but rather went crossed Morecambe Bay to the south  [33].

Raine [34] following Simeon [30] tells us that the monks carrying Cuthbert's relics eventually found their way to the mouth of the Cumberland Derwent at Workington and were planning on heading across to Ireland to escape the Norsemen but a storm arose and drove them back. Woolf dates this to around 880 [8] It was felt that the storm represented Cuthbert's will not to go overseas. If this is in any sense a true story, it suggests that in the late 9th Century, Cumbria west of the Pennines was seen as safe territory for the Northumbrians. Or at least safe Christian territory.

Taken together, the material Anglo-Saxon remains, the dedications to Northumbrian saints, the Anglo-Saxon place-names from this period, and what history that we have suggests that following the Northumbrian expansion into Berwickshire, Lothian, Dumfriesshire, Cumberland and Westmorland and even parts of Lanarkshire, resulted in a significant Anglicisation of previously British territory, similar to that which happened in Devon and Somerset and the Welsh border counties, but not in Wales, or to the same extent in Cornwall.


Woolf argues that the recovery of Anglian coinage from Whithorn dating to the mid 860s indicates that Northumbrian governmental control was maintained in that area until that time [8]. In 866, Danes attacked and took York. They had come from Ireland where they had been active since around 851 [8].  Traditionally this was the establishment of the Viking kingdom of York, though Woolf argues that it was not as clear cut [8]. Woolf says that the Vikings then used anchored in the mouth of the Tyne and from there attacked the Picts and Strathclyde. In 876 they sacked Carlisle, which of course up until then was probably still under Northumbrian rule. At this time the Vikings began to settle, at least east of the Pennines. 

No comments:

Post a Comment